Hergott: Soft tissue injuries from a crash can last a lifetime

It's a scientific reality that a percentage of those suffering soft tissue injuries in crashes will never fully recover.

This is the second column of a series I am writing to expose common arguments that some insurance adjusters make that are so lacking in logic, science and law that I consider them an attempt at cheating.

This one has to do with a willful blindness to the scientific reality that a percentage of those suffering soft tissue injuries in crashes will never fully recover from their injuries.

I say “willful blindness” because even orthopaedic surgeons, the medical specialty favoured by ICBC to provide “independent” opinions against injured victims, will agree with that scientific reality when cross examined.

This scientific reality is never shared with you. Instead, it is assumed that you will fully recover, which is thankfully the reality for a much higher percentage of injury victims. That assumption is bolstered by optimism expressed by your medical doctor and others on your medical team.

Optimism is an important medical tool. The mind is a powerful healer. The more optimistic you are about your own recovery, the more likely your optimism will be borne out. I am certainly not saying that your injuries and the symptoms you are feeling are “just in your head”. No, they are very real. There is an established scientific interrelation, though, between the psychological and the physical.

If the optimism is not borne out, though, it is unfair and hurtful to say: “You should be better by now”.  You absolutely wish that you were better by now. Certainly, the inattentive driver “should” not have crashed into the back of your vehicle. There’s no concept, though that you “should” be better by now when you clearly are not.

By not enjoying a complete recovery, you have joined the unfortunate minority statistic of those for whom an inattentive driver has permanently harmed.

It is also unfair to point to other occupants of the same vehicle, who joined the majority of crash victims in enjoying a complete recovery, as an indication that you should not still be having symptoms. That’s as nonsense and hurtful as telling anyone contracting a disease that afflicts a minority of people that it’s somehow their fault for joining that unlucky minority.

You are dealing with a bodily injury claims adjuster who, you believe, has expertise in this stuff. He or she is a representative of the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia, a crown corporation, which you have paid insurance premiums to year after year. That inherent credibility causes those words to sow seeds of doubt in your mind about your entitlement to fair, financial compensation for your injuries and losses.

“Maybe there is something wrong with me that I haven’t recovered,” “Maybe there was something more that I could have done which would have led to my recovery.”

Those seeds of doubt help the claims adjuster to convince you to accept a level of compensation that is far below what is fair. It is a level of unfairness that I call cheating and it is every bit as distasteful in my view as those pathetic worms who try to cheat the insurance company.

 

 

Just Posted

Youth athletes get $22k from Kelowna builder

Mission Group supports a group of ten elite cyclists and triathletes from around Kelowna

UPDATE: Tsunami warning cancelled for coastal British Columbia

Warning issued following 7.9 earthquake off Kodiak, AK

Coordinated search finds missing Kelowna boy

All available police resources were called in to help find a missing boy Monday afternoon

Kelowna students leave for downhill challenge

A group of students from UBCO is ready for annual concrete toboggan race

Kelowna’s Serwa named to Olympic team

Kelsey Serwa is one of eight Canadian ski cross athletes headed to PyeongChang

Your Jan. 23 Morning Brief

Check out the top stories of the day in the Okanagan-Shuswap with Carmen Weld’s Black Press Morning Brief.

Taylor: Humans the theory makers

Lake Country columnist Jim Taylor writes weekly in the Calendar

Man faces 48 charges in string of random Toronto shootings

The string of unprovoked shootings began Jan.9, say police

Slayer adds Penticton to North American tour

Slayer adds the South Okanagan Events Centre as a stop on their last tour

‘Shape of Water’ producer, Christopher Plummer among Canadian Oscar nominees

Guillermo del Toro film about merman romance earns 13 nominations

Vancouver Canucks confirm participation in NHL Young Stars

Canucks confirmed participation, at least for this year, in the NHL Young Stars event in Penticton

Canada, TPP agrees to revised deal without the United States

Canada and the remaining members of the Trans-Pacific Partnership have agreed to a revised trade agreement

Tsunami warnings 101: Canada

Here are some things to know about tsunami alerts in Canada and how they work

Rogers Media cuts ties with Vice Canada

Rogers Media and Vice Canada are ending their three-year-old partnership, pulling Viceland TV channel off the air

Most Read