Hergott: Ruling on assisted suicide law challenge receives applause

I couldn’t help reacting emotionally—yes, with tears—to the Supreme Court of British Columbia decision on assisted suicide.

I couldn’t help reacting emotionally—yes, with tears—to the Supreme Court of British Columbia decision on assisted suicide, released by Madam Justice Lynn Smith earlier this month.

The decision was released electronically through the B.C. Supreme Court website at 11:30 a.m., and I was watching for it.

The website is easy to find—simply enter “Supreme Court of BC” into Google and it’s the first result.

Click next on “Judgments,” then “Recent Judgments,” and scroll to June 15, 2012, where the decision is listed as Carter v. Canada (Attorney General).

If you have any difficulty accessing the judgment, email me and I’ll gladly send you a copy.

I am not going to summarize the decision in this column. The 395-page ruling has had lots of media coverage.

I became interested in the issue of assisted suicide through Gloria Taylor, a West Kelowna resident who is one of the successful plaintiffs in the lawsuit. At Gloria’s suggestion, I attended a debate in April 2012, hosted by the Centre for Inquiry Okanagan and very ably moderated by CBC Daybreak host Chris Walker.

I learned that there are good arguments for prohibiting assisted suicide.

But the more I learned about Taylor’s fatal neurodegenerative disease, ALS or Lou Gehrig’s disease, the more I was convinced that this particular woman, and those similarly afflicted, absolutely must be permitted to arrange a merciful end to their lives when life becomes unbearable, and the person suffering has become too weak to bring about an end to the suffering themselves.

I became angry that Gloria had to bring a lawsuit against the federal government, challenging the constitutionality of the Criminal Code’s absolute prohibition against assisted suicide. It was offensive to me that the federal government would not pro-actively step up to carefully consider what could be done to change the Criminal Code so as to provide for an exception for citizens like Gloria Taylor.

In my view, it was another of many examples of politics getting in the way of what is right.

Tough issues like this are dangerous for our political leaders to take on.

We now have the Supreme Court of British Columbia declaring the absolute prohibition against assisted suicide in the Criminal Code illegal, because it runs contrary to our rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The federal government is now faced with an important choice.

One option is to appeal the decision to the British Columbia Court of Appeal, and then when they lose again to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, ensuring that the legal point of the constitutionality of a dated Criminal Code provision is litigated to death.

Another option is to do what they should have done in the first place, which is to lead the country in carefully considering and crafting public policy in such a way that Gloria Taylor, and those like her, are permitted a way to end their suffering when they become too weak to do so themselves while protecting the most vulnerable among us from abuses that could flow from unrestricted assisted suicide.

Please choose the right option.

This column is intended to provide general information about injury claims. It is not a substitute for retaining a lawyer to provide legal advice specifically pertaining to your case.

Just Posted

Kelowna Boat Show highlights abandoned boat program

The 24th annual Kelowna Boat Show hits shores April 27 and 28.

West Kelowna fire under control

A fire broke out just above Bear Creek Provincial Park Monday

Kelowna’s Korczak, Canada en route to U18 quarter-finals

Kaedan Korczak and Team Canada play Latvia Thursday

Kelowna driver searches for man who allegedly tried to run him off the road

The driver said he just missed a biker trying to avoid a collision

Social media flooded with love for woman found dead on Kelowna beach

“We lost a sister. Because that is what we are it is a sisterhood and I can’t help but feel anything but sadness.”

VIDEO: Okanagan fire victim Amy Hansen speaks out on the loss of her four pets

A gofundme page has been started for Hansen, with $1,140 raised of a $5000 goal to help her rebuild

SPCA investigating hen cull at Shuswap egg farm

Egg farm regulator says they are confident cull at was done properly

‘Cutthroat’ sport of wine tasting happening now in the Okanagan

BC Tasting Games are underway with competitions in three Okanagan communities.

Okanagan Rail Trail a popular place

Thousands pack North Okanagan section over long weekend

B.C. men challenge constitutionality of Canada’s secret no-fly list

Parvkar Singh Dulai says he received a “denial of boarding” notification under the no-fly program last May 17

Murder on B.C. property didn’t need to be disclosed before sale, court rules

Buyer had tried to break contract after learning a man with ties to crime had been murdered there

Kelowna pimp faces 4 year sentence

In court the details of how Simon Rypiak lured 4 women into prostitution revealed

B.C.’s largest Vaisakhi festival target of threatening Facebook post: Surrey RCMP

Police say they are investigating the posts on Facebook, after local MLA forwarded screenshots

Pug life: B.C. town boasts waggish list of dog names

Freedom-of-information request lists most ‘pupular’ dog names registered in White Rock

Most Read