Working with temporary truths

A glossy, full-colour 52-page booklet landed in my mailbox the other day. It offered courses on everything from music appreciation to geology, from calculus to classical mythology.

A glossy, full-colour 52-page booklet landed in my mailbox the other day. It offered courses on everything from music appreciation to geology, from calculus to classical mythology.

Junk mail usually heads straight for the wastebasket, unread. The trouble with this particular mailing was that I’d like to take all of these courses. Well, perhaps not the History of Hitler’s Empire. But almost everything else.

I am, you see, what a friend once called “an information junkie.” I don’t want to be a specialist who knows more and more about less and less.

I have a conviction, deep inside, that all knowledge is connected. It all fits together, like a billion-piece jigsaw puzzle.

In such a puzzle, each piece matters. Each piece is true, in its own way. No single piece is The Whole Truth.

Except in religion.

Here the evangelical atheists – Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris, and their ilk – may have done us a favour. Whether their attacks on religion are well founded or not, they have forced many people to consider religion’s exclusive claims.

Religion, because it claims to deal with ultimate truth, has difficulty dealing with partial truths and temporary understandings – the kind of thing that conventional sciences deal with constantly.

I think we might well learn from scientific practice. First, it allows theories to be disproved. When Copernicus showed that the planets, including the earth, orbited the sun, he excised 15 centuries of belief based on Ptolemy’s model of an earth-centred universe. Similarly, when William Harvey identified how blood circulates in the body, he eclipsed previous understandings that went back to the Greek surgeon Galen.

But when was the last time you heard of a religious faith formally discarding a historic doctrine?

Second, science allows temporary truths to be subsumed into larger truths.

When I was in school, we learned two inflexible laws – Conservation of Matter, and Conservation of Energy. Then Einstein and the Manhattan Project showed that matter and energy were related

Today, sub-atomic particles seem to behave in ways contrary to the laws of astronomy. So scientists search for a Grand Unified Theory of Everything that will somehow tie up all the loose ends (not a pun about String Theory).

Frankly, I strongly suspect that such an integrated theory will simply reveal new gaps in our knowledge.

Science teaches us that truths are always partial. They tell us something. They point us further down the road. But they are never final.

I wish religion and theology could recognize that principle. After all, Moses’ perception of God was not the same as Micah’s. Jesus’ God feels quite different from Joshua’s.

That’s obvious to anyone who actually reads the Bible. But it doesn’t square with official doctrines about a changeless God.

In religious matters, as in science, we need to be open to a host of partial truths. Some will replace previous truths. Others will connect with each other to reveal a pattern, a flow, a direction.

Wearing doctrinal blinders merely prevents us from seeing anything beyond our own preconceptions.

Jim Taylor welcomes comments. Send e-mails to

Just Posted

Kelowna’s formerly homeless showing support for Journey Home project

Kelowna’s Lived Experience Circle on Homelessness (LECoH) is part of the Journey Home Strategy

Rockets open weekend with win over Spokane

The Rockets host Kamloops in game two of the weekend Saturday night

Peachland researchers warn public to be on alert for dead bats

White Nose Syndrome, a deadly bat disease, has been found south of B.C.

Rescued Kelowna skier shares appreciation of COSAR team

A skier was found out of bounds near Big White by Central Okanagan Search and Rescue

Lake Country businesses recognized by community

The Lake Country Chamber of Commerce held its annual Business Excellence Awards Friday

Music Rundown: Who you should be watching play live this week

Fill your calendar this week with these great shows

One of B.C.’s newest citizens reflects on the value of immigration

“People who come by choice to another country will do everything to contribute to that country.”

Indigenous leaders, politicians say Trans Mountain report flawed

The National Energy Board has endorsed an expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline a second time

UPDATE: Reports of rashes prompt closure of all Harrison Hot Springs pools

Public pool available after Fraser Health shut down all five mineral pools until further notice

Legislation to protect B.C. farmland comes into effect

Regulations enhance food security, encourage long-term farming

Letter: Money buys untrustworthy politicians

Vernon - There are several ways to redirecting the anger of distraught, disenfranchised members…

Letter: West Kelowna tax increase doesn’t make sense

The budget was prepared based on a three per cent property tax increase.

Most Read