The foundation of all laws

An American correspondent vented about the National Rifle Association’s mantra – “Guns don’t kill people; people kill people.”

In one sense, it’s true. A gun cannot kill people unless a human loads it and pulls the trigger. A gun that stays locked in its case is perfectly safe.

In fact, all slogans contain a snippet of truth – that’s what makes them attractive. All slogans also ignore the rest of the truth – that’s what makes them dangerous.

So it’s equally true, as my correspondent noted, “that vehicles don’t kill people; people kill people.”

You can see the parallel. A car cannot kill someone unless a human starts the engine and drives it. A vehicle immobile in its garage cannot run anyone down.

Then she went on, “We set in place lots of restrictions to make it harder for people to kill people with vehicles (no bayonets on bumpers; no TV screens on steering wheels, etc.)… Why do we substitute ideology for common sense when it comes to gun control?”

In fact, the NRA argument could be applied to almost anything constructed by humans.

 

•    Bombs don’t kill people; people build bombs, aim them, drop them…

•    Faulty buildings don’t kill people; architects planned them, contractors cheated on materials, construction…

•    Land mines don’t maim people; people manufacture those mines, buy those mines, place them where others will walk…

•    Toxic pollutants don’t poison people; people ignore environmental standards and regulations…

•    Economic flimflam doesn’t hurt homeowners; people write the mortgage policies, sign the papers…

 

No doubt those rationalizations will provide great consolation to those who have lost lives or limbs, homes or health, respect or freedom.

You might notice that all those assertions have a common thread – the problem is people. I’m surprised no one has suggested the obvious solution – ban people! If we had no people, we’d have no guns, no bombs, no land mines, no collapsing roofs, no industrial chemicals…

Doesn’t that make sense?

Of course not. And by extension, neither do most self-serving slogans. Merely repeating a mantra doesn’t absolve guns – or cars, or land mines, or mortgage clauses – of having devastating effects when misused or abused.

Most people accept responsibility for what they do with human technology. But a few don’t. A few construct shoddy buildings, or drive while drunk. A few invent financial scams, cheat on environmental regulations, or use guns to settle disagreements.

That’s why we have regulations that require cars to meet safety standards. Why we have building codes. Why 156 countries (the U.S. being the most significant exception) have outlawed land mines. And that’s why we have – in Canada, at least – laws restricting hate speech.

I see no reason why guns should be exempt from that principle.

We need limits on guns, just as we need them on any human activity that can harm others. That’s why we have governments. To establish ground rules that protect most of us from the unscrupulous few who are unwilling to accept the principle that people shouldn’t harm other people.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jim Taylor is an Okanagan Centre author of 17 books and several thousand magazine and newspaper articles. He welcomes comments; rewrite@shaw.ca.

Just Posted

Kelowna mom concerned with needles found at Knox Mountain Park

Maria Beinarowitz, who has a five-year-old son, said she’s noticed a fair amount at the Kelowna park

UBC Okanagan Heat athletes nominated for awards

28th Annual Athletic Awards Celebration will recognize the star athletes

Updated: Scene cleared after accident near Ellison Lake

An accident near Ellison Lake near Kelowna and Lake Country is causing traffic delays

‘The whole city has changed’: Kelowna woman in New Zealand reacts to mosque attacks

An expatriate and Muslim students at UBC Okanagan deeply affected by white supremacist shooting

Swoop brings in cheap flights from Kelowna to Vegas

This will be the low-cost airlines second flight route out of Kelowna

Temperatures on the rise for the Okanagan Valley

Okanagan-Shuswap weekday weather update

Dozens of B.C. temperature records smashed as spring brings early warmth

Squamish Airport was the hottest spot in all of Canada on Monday

VIDEO: Vancouver police release clip of ‘life-altering’ 2018 assault in search for suspects

The attack happened at about 2 a.m. on Mar. 31, 2018, outside Pierre’s Champagne Lounge in Yaletown

Hackers seek holes in B.C. Hydro power grid, auditor says

System meets standards, but local outages still a concern

B.C. RCMP stop cyclist with no helmet, find out he’s wanted for murder

Kyle Antonio Dias, 19, to face second-degree murder charge in Toronto

British Columbia Teachers’ Federation welcomes new leader

Teri Mooring will take over as president this summer

Vernon ordered to reinstate terminated firefighters caught having sex at work

City believes arbitration board erred, exploring options

Disappearance of Merritt cowboy now deemed suspicious: police

Ben Tyner was reported missing when his riderless horse was discovered on a logging road

Distillers hope federal budget scraps alcohol escalator tax

Tax hike set for April 1, marking third automatic increase in three years time

Most Read