Mental mazes

Consider this brain-twister: “The following sentence is true. The previous sentence is false.”

 

Consider this brain-twister: “The following sentence is true. The previous sentence is false.”

The first sentence asserts that the second is true. But if the second is true, the first must be false. But if the first is false, then the second sentence must also be false, which means that the first could be true after all….”

Around and around we go.

From some editing colleagues, I’ve learned that this kind of construction is called an Epimenides paradox.

Epimenides was a Cretan – that is, a citizen of Crete, not a cretin — who invented the famous paradox, “All Cretans are liars.”

You see the problem –- if all Cretans are liars, then he himself must be lying, which means that his assertion is false, and therefore all Cretans are not liars, in which case this Cretan might be telling the truth, but if he is, he must be lying…

Around and around, again.

My colleagues called it a “self-reflexive puzzle.”

Epimenides, by the way, originated a famous line usually attributed to St. Paul. In Acts 17:28, Paul says, “In him we live and move and have our being.” Paul plagiarized shamelessly; Epimenides wrote that line six centuries earlier.

The Bible, interestingly, contains its own self-reflexive puzzle, which by some coincidence also involves Paul.

When I talk with people of a somewhat conservative theology, they may make an assertion about, say, the origins of life.

If I challenge them, they reply that they know it’s true, because it’s in the Bible.

How they can be sure the Bible is true? “Because the Bible says so,” they reply.

It’s not really a contradiction – more a pattern of circular reasoning that cites itself for authority.

Pushed, these conservatives usually quote a line from Paul’s letter to Timothy: “All Scripture is inspired by God.”

And since Paul’s letter is included in our Scriptures, it too must be divinely authoritative.

Except that when Paul wrote that letter, the only Scripture was what Christians now call the Old Testament. The New Testament didn’t exist yet. Therefore we cannot claim divine inspiration for Paul’s assertion.

Yes we can, the conservative replies. Because a later letter from Peter, leader of the church after Jesus’ death, defines Paul’s letters as among “the other Scriptures.”

So Peter validates Paul. Paul validates Scripture. Scripture validates Peter.

Language guru James Harbeck likens this process to “plugging an extension cord into itself.”

Harbeck offers a practical illustration: “It’s like weighing an object. You have to rest the scale on something that is not part of what you are weighing.”

Epimenides’ paradox makes sense — if he sets himself outside the Cretan community he refers to.

Similarly, the biblical conundrum also sorts itself out nicely, if we’re willing to accept that both Peter and Paul set themselves outside the Scriptures they were referring to.

The problem is not Peter. Or Paul. Or Epimenides, for that matter. It’s our tendency to assign absolute authority to mere words, without taking into account the context in which they were uttered.

 

 

 

Jim Taylor is an Okanagan Centre author of 17 books and several thousand magazine and newspaper articles. He welcomes comments; rewrite@shaw.ca.

Just Posted

Sister of cancer victim cycles across Canada to raise awareness

Her journey started on May 14 and will end in early August

Top women’s hockey player Natalie Spooner coming to the Okanagan

Natalie Spooner special guest at annual Grindstone Award Foundation charity weekend in Kelowna

Woman in hospital after being thrown off horse

She was airlifted to Kelowna General Hospital from Okanagan Falls

Update: Washed out South Okanagan road temporarily closed for assessment

A portion of Eastside Road, south of Penticton, appears to be crumbling into Skaha Lake

Okanagan Regional Library hosts famous author

Author of The Woo Woo, Lindsay Wong will be in Kelowna Tuesday

VIDEO: It’s warming up across the Okanagan Valley

Grey skies are expected to fade and the sun looks like it’s here to stay

Update: Plan to see more smoke from South Okanagan wildfire

Richter Creek wildfire, 12 kilometres west of Osoyoos, is an estimated 400 hectares

Growing wildfire prompts evacuation of High Level, Alta.

Chuckegg Creek fire has been burning for several day, but grew substantially Sunday

Okanagan art gallery releases their theme

Fine arts painting will be the point of focus for this year’s event

South Okanagan search and rescue help injured climber

Search and rescue called on the assistance of a helicopter to help retrieve an injured hiker

Okanagan nature centre fundraiser goes western

Allan Brook’s Nature Centre Wine and Wild West Fundraiser is on July 6

Marriage proposal on the big screen at Enderby drive-in

Kelowna man gets engaged in front of hundreds to Vernon sweetheart

Take-home drug testing kits latest pilot to help curb B.C.’s overdose crisis

Researchers look to see if fentanyl testing could be a useful tool for those who use drugs alone

Firefighters respond to bus fire on Highway 1

Smoke in coach bus reported to have been caused by overheating, driver and passengers safe

Most Read